Well, Dimmo said almost everything I wanted to.
Even if mkuh's movie had some very nice actions, I couldn't enjoy them under these circumstances (low quality, sound bugs, recam problems).
I just want to reply to a few comments:
Scooby said: '...in kta there were only few nice frags...'
- ONLY A FEW?! If those weren't all worth for a movie I don't know what frags are!
Foen said: 'netQuake Brotherwars 2 - qw movie'
- As the name says it's a netQuake movie (just plain Quake1), not QuakeWorld. BTW Brotherwars 2 has longer intro and outro than the action itself! For QW I'd rather recommend: Dag Def Extreme 2, GZ Done Extreme or Frags Done Satanic 2 - Refragged.
VenoM said: 'man, what do you exept [=expect?] from q2 movies??'
- Watch Optimizer's "Pure Oldschool Scandinavia" which is the BEST Q2 movie IMO. (www.optimizer.se)
problem is kta movie wasnt so great, it was for sure made a lot of better than this 1, but for me without those all effects this movie is 8 and kta 9 why? cose in kta there were only few nice frags and tragic music and here things which i require from q2 movie - frags frags frags and music, we better stop talking and start doing our own movies !:]
V3nom you said what do i expect from q2 movies and answer is that expect same from q2 movies than from any other game movies.
And i'll give you some good movies, download these and come here and give 5 "full stars" to this movie.
- Freeform - q3 trickjump movie
- Annihilation - q3 fragmovie
- aAa-2003 - aAa clanmvie ut2k3, q3, cs
- matrix renaissanse - cs clanmovie
- netQuake Brotherwars 2 - qw movie
And you think "you can't make that nice movies from q2" then watch kta movie again, it wasn't too far from those 5
yea, im never were good movie maker because for me movie is good when have good frags and nice music (good to be sync with frags) thats all thx for comments
nice was simple but nice, i prefer original stuff like in ergo movie, film effects sux but it doesnt matter for me, music, hmm i hate hh and rock/metal but for sure i rather watch q2 with hh than rock while most movies 99,99? are with some #$#^#^ rock/metal, last thing, most important are frags, all those movies i have seen in last few months were so fuckin sad etc no good frags, this 1 has a lot!!!!!! of very nice frags, dunno that even the most of those are realesed q2 movies, thats a q2 movie ppl frags+music we arent COLUMBIA PICTURES overall its 8 for me
I dont find words to describe the intro .. it was shocking. Btw what the maple leafs has to do with marihuana?
There was some railgun sounds but i heard only two of them synced on the right moment.
Recamming is mostly ok, but can you explain what were you thinking when you left statusbars and crosshair? Another thing that looked clumsy were models dissapearing in recams.
Sound is uncompressed again.
The frags were quite good. Skilled movie maker would had done a good movie from that footage. And what comes to the dm1 water handgrenade frags, i think they are mkuh's trademark. It brings at least some personality to this movie.
Mkuh frags 3 doesnt deserve more than 4 points. Progress from your previous movies is hardly markable. You seem to learn only one thing at once. If you are going to do movies in future, you really should consider again doing them in .dm2 format.
I think rate tells everything.
- no editing, only little with keygrip.
- no music syncs
- boring frags
- xx same kind of grenadefrags near railgun, booooring.
- nothing good
+ nothing? maybe few frags were video material. but that's it.