European Duel League

	Menu

	» News » Forum » Rules » Players » Awards » Schedule » All matches » Player stats » League stats » Articles » Polls » Crew » Users

	Tables

Profile

	Powered by

	Services

	» 2x2? » ADL » AmericaQ2L » Balkan 2v2 » BDL » BRDL » demosquad » Edge » EDL » EUROQ2L » Forum » gibblördag » JUMP » Kubus » NADL » NADML » NDML » NiDML » PTDL » Quake 2 » RDL » RDM » SSD » virtuosos

	Links

	» Tworzenie WWW

	Latest news

	2022-08-16 Season #20 2020-11-10 Start Playing! 2020-10-31 Season 19 Groups 2020-10-04 Season 19 Open 2019-12-20 Playoffs have started! 2019-10-21 Groups Set - Schedule ... 2019-10-17 Initial Groups - Peer ... 2019-09-26 Emails/Passwords

	Latest matches

	Info

	EDL #20 IRC: #EDL \| Demos: http://demos.q2players.org Sign ups: off

Match: sofiene vs newash

» Summary « » Description « » Comments « » New comment «

Summary

sofiene vs newash
Type:	Div 4 B
Referee:	Welkin
Date:	2011-12-20 14:00
Score:	2:0
Frags:	0:-150
Maps:	w/o, w/o
Scores:	0:-75, 0:-75
Demos:	———

Description

Forced in newash's favor. 2011-12-17 21:00 CET

Rescheduled.

sofiene picked q2dm3. newash picked q2rdm5.

q2dm3 was accidentally played with timelimit 20, due to server complications. At the 15:00 mark sofiene was in the lead, but at the 20:00 mark newash won. The game should have been aborted straight away, and restarted with timelimit 15, but since neither player made this happen, the game is now considered sofiene's win. However, if either player wishes, he may demand to have this map replayed altogether.

newash dropped out. Gave final confirmation on email, Jan 9. Game turns into a forfeit on his behalf.

Comments

VIZAARI	2011-12-23 20:18
	Why won't he replay the map, what's the big deal. It's better to get a new chance.
Gravgon	2011-12-23 12:59
	Yes! Thank you
MCS_FaderJok0	2011-12-22 18:25
	Gravgon: Wasn't that vs. Turricane?
Gravgon	2011-12-22 17:49
	Replaying the map is consistent with the EDL's past decisions. Remember Optimus vs. Jakkari a couple of seasons ago. The match was played on a server where say_team messages could be read by the opponent. Optimus had won but the match had to be replayed because of wrong server settings. Just wanted to lawyer this shit a little bit
TeiOch	2011-12-22 11:48
	" What more can you ask for? ' Justice " Then, re-play dm3 ? Maybe the actual game should be a neutral w/o until that ? Then it would be only 1:0 to sofiene, solid justice, no? The game was a bit messy. I mean, server settings. But there was the ping issue. But I think after each game on that server, the tl is set back to org. 20 mins (?) and tl was changed to 15 first by newash, then they tried a 1 min game to see the overtime. After that, game was reset to 20 min. So that's why the game was at 20 mins when they actually started. Sofiene did call a timeout, and voted tl 15 that somehow never got thru..maybe newash forgot to vote? In any way, I reminded these guys when it was 10 seconds left (14:50): since spec talk was allowed I wrote directly into the match and said: 10 seconds Left! But I think neither of them was seeing it (in the heat of the game...). In one way I gotta admit.... if both were thinking it was 5 mins left when the tl 15 mark was passed, that they thought they had played only 10 mins, that affects the game greatly. EG. newash would think yes! i have 5 more minutes to turn this game, which he did. Sofiene could think, awright gotta stay focuz 5 more mins and not loose. Then the score turned ... it's just a bit strange .... what is right and wrong? imo, the game was 'a bit' too unintentionally wrong - the game should have a double w/o. Im not taking any side, just trying to see logically what is 'right' and 'wrong': what the outcome should be. About rdm5, yes mrt left really quick, but I gotta also admit one thing here, since he was spawned at the start it affected the spawn system most likely. maybe sofiene/newash would have gotten totally different spawns if mrt never joined (i dont care if it was a bug or not). .....I'm a bit into Welkin's thinking: 20 min at the start of dm3 - game should've been restarted! - mrt was in one of the team in the actual game of rdm5, if mere only 1-3 seconds, game should've been restarted! Home / away was also an option which is bad that newash never thought of if he wasnt happy about the server. well, few of my cents.
newash	2011-12-22 08:30
	Talking 'smtg like that' means you are not competent, or you want misslead the people. The fact you offered ot 2 min counted by us, doesnt provide anything coz i didnt agree on such case.
newash	2011-12-22 08:23
	' When you noticed it was tl 20, and you didn't accept whatever the score would be at 15:00, why didn't you then leave the team, and have the map restarted? ' It was so messy server, so (as sofiene) i accept any actual conditions. Because i was sure that if the game will be not valid (it seems not to be) i will get w/o over sofiene. There are no rule in rule sheet about counting score at 15 when we play 20. Sofiene seems to continue the game as he accept that we are plaing tl 20. ' If for some reason Muerte was in sofiene's team at the start of rdm5 (of the actual game, I assume?), why didn't you have that map restarted as well?' Because i got mh spawn. And it wasnt my fault that mrt were in sofiene team. It was serwer issue, on which i agreed to play under 'w/o condition' ' was 5.1.8 enforced? ' No it wasnt. Noone offered this. Its our duty or right? ' > [22:20] <newash> sofeiene, you agreed that if game will not be valid you will take w/o Reply: What does that mean? ' It means that if game will not be valid (by admins) due to messy server settings the game will be turned in w/o in my favor. ' > Do sofiene provide you such an information? Reply: No. Did you?' ' As i said: I ask IsB if we can take a channel and talk with sofiene together. He replyed he got all facts. I feeled like only sofiene's side is taken under consideration. ' was he? Reply: I don't know. Did he? ' I dont know. ' What more can you ask for? ' Justice
sofiene	2011-12-22 08:11
	1st : i wanted to play in that server cause it was the most suitable server for both of us (about ping) cause my ping in other servers was 90 or more. 2nd: we tested the overtime,david came with the idea of voting tl 1 and see what happen,and after 1 min the overtime was 5 mins,so i asked if there is a tie,match ends after 2 mins. also,after the begin of the game,some spec said "20 mins ? " so i timed out and voted 15 mins but i think it didnt worked and the time in the server stayed as 20 mins. 3rd : in the very 1st begin of rdm5,mrt joined a team (server bug i think ) i timed and said "mrt wtf" he left team and said server bug or smth like that,i asked newsh if he wants "re or continue" he just said "continue "or smth like that,i have demo if you want (mrt joining the team didnt effected the match,it was just for 1-2 secs) 4th: im not EDL admin,i dont take any decisions or interfere in anything related to adminig the EDL. finally,its not that i want to win or anything,if newash wants,we can replay dm3,just if i got time and good connection.
Welkin	2011-12-22 07:40
	> There was no possibility to set overtime 2 min on this server. There were spects allowed to chat. At the beggining of rdm5 there muerte was in sofiene team(?!). And even we set tl 15 before the game there were no changes and tl was 20. Reply: Rule 5.2.1. + When you noticed it was tl 20, and you didn't accept whatever the score would be at 15:00, why didn't you then leave the team, and have the map restarted? + If for some reason Muerte was in sofiene's team at the start of rdm5 (of the actual game, I assume?), why didn't you have that map restarted as well? > I agreed to play there to provide sofiene best ping possible. + I agreed to play on this crap server only with condition above. Reply: That's kind of you, but 5.1.5 + 5.2.1. On a sidenote, was 5.1.8 enforced? > [22:20] <newash> sofeiene, you agreed that if game will not be valid you will take w/o Reply: What does that mean? > Do sofiene provide you such an information? Reply: No. Did you? > I asked IsBjorn for a channel when sofiene was talking to him after rdm5 (when i was like a fool on server without an idea where sofiene is), but he said he got all facts, was he? Reply: I don't know. Did he? newash, it's not like we're favoring sofiene right now, and it has been declared that you have the right to demand having the map replayed. What more can you ask for?
David	2011-12-22 06:55
	n/c sofiene
newash	2011-12-22 06:43
	There was no possibility to set overtime 2 min on this server. There were spects allowed to chat. At the beggining of rdm5 there muerte was in sofiene team(?!). And even we set tl 15 before the game there were no changes and tl was 20. I agreed to play there to provide sofiene best ping possible. [22:16] <newash> where are you? im waiting on you [22:17] <sofiene__> im asking an admin [22:17] <newash> dont be funny [22:17] <sofiene__> im not [22:17] <sofiene__> we played 20 mins in dm3 [22:18] <newash> how it comes? [22:19] <newash> which admin are talking to? [22:19] <sofiene__> isbjorn [22:20] <newash> sofeiene, you agreed that if game will not be valid you will take w/o [22:21] <sofiene__> yes,but we played 20 mins [22:21] <sofiene__> edl = 15 mins [22:21] <newash> anyway just remember your statement [22:21] <sofiene__> i do remmember it I agreed to play on this crap server only with condition above. Do sofiene provide you such an information? I asked IsBjorn for a channel when sofiene was talking to him after rdm5 (when i was like a fool on server without an idea where sofiene is), but he said he got all facts, was he?
Welkin	2011-12-22 05:11
	Fader: you're free to get in touch with all the server admins and make that happen. brikete: no, sofiene is not an admin. Anyone can make a mistake.
brikete	2011-12-22 02:56
	newash, you still owe a game against APKIS^^. You cant resign! Isnt sofiene one of the edl admins? even nubadmin wision didnt make such childish mistakes.
MCS_FaderJok0	2011-12-21 20:45
	How about instead of setting the default time to 20 minutes, you set it to 15? The majority of matches played on the servers are friendly pickups or EDL matches, and it's a real hassle to time in every time we ready up and change the timelimit, and it's especially annoying when it's during an EDL match.
Welkin	2011-12-21 19:13
	I really don't get it. Instead of resigning from EDL, why doesn't he just ask to replay the map, which has been declared to be his right?
Delita	2011-12-21 18:29
	If the games played with 20 minutes but should be 15, whoever is in the lead at 15 minutes wins. The law has spoken.
newash	2011-12-21 17:05
	I feel fucked. Facts are different. Cutting straight : I resign from EDL.
sofiene	2011-12-17 17:03
	thx to newash for agreement to reshedule
newash	2011-12-17 15:28
	Rescheduled 20.12 Tues 21:00 CET due to sofiene info about lags and pl. Luck pot is empty now
TeiOch	2011-12-16 03:31
	geLuck

New comment

You have to register/login first. Register

^^^

0.029